Gorgeous in grey: the Pelikan M1005 Stresemann

A long road led to the Fedex man knocking at my door this week with a package from Pelikan, containing the M1005 Stresemann special edition.

dscf6956.jpg

To understand why this was a big event for me, we have to go back to July 2017, when I picked up an M1000 in classic black, with a super-juicy, super flexible fine nib.

Why did I get that M1000? The M1000 has always, it seems to me, been an utter bargain, sat unfairly in the Montblanc 149’s shadow. Both have huge gold nibs. Made in Germany. Piston fillers. Screw caps. Classic styling. Flagship size. But the Pelikan has two distinct advantages over the Montblanc: much keener pricing (you can pick a basic black version up for about £350, versus nearly twice that for a new 149) and a surprisingly springy nib.

But for all its qualities, I eventually sold that pen. I decided it was too big for me, for a start. But a significant factor in the sale was the gold trim, which Pelikan designates on all its pens with a “0” at the end (M800, M600, etc). Back in 2017 I was even more dead-set against gold trim than I am now.

I always hoped Pelikan would bring out an edition of the M1000 in rhodium trim, which Pelikan designates with a “5” (M805, M605, etc). M1005s did exist, but they were super rare and commensurately expensive. So I sadly watched as again and again another M605 or M805 special edition came out, leaving the M1000 untouched.

I stayed interested despite my many other frustrations with Pelikan, mainly over the quality of its nibs, and this Spring, my prayers were answered. No Ocean Swirl or other fancy colour scheme, but an M1005 Stresemann was announced. If you’re new to Pelikan, the Stresemann is a sober affair, designed after a politician’s grey pinstripe suit.

DSCF6947

For a while I had owned an M805 in Stresemann, and the colour scheme is timelessly classy. Most importantly, the Stresemann’s trim is silver, not gold. At last.

So, while I held off as long as I could through the months of production delays, I knew that eventually I would buy it.

And here it is.

dscf6953.jpg

My first impressions surprised me. No longer did the size seem cumbersome; the M100x is a big pen, sure, but not comically so. I guess I’ve become accustomed to larger designs.

dscf6962.jpg

L-R: Visconti Homo Sapiens, Nakaya 17mm Portable Cigar, Montblanc 149 Expression, Pelikan M1005, Conid Kingsize, Namiki Urushi 20, Lamy 2000

This time, the M1005 immediately fit like a glove, with a section much longer than the M800-series.

dscf6958.jpg

The design suits the frame of the M1005 perfectly. I’ve always felt that Pelikan has an eye for proportions, and the various silver trim rings, black plastic and the pearlescent grey stripes result in a look that’s definitively work-friendly, but not boring.

DSCF6944

Turning the pen around in my hands, the quality control is good. Every surface is well polished, trim rings fit flush, threads are smooth, everything lines up — even the lines on the binde are almost completely straight, with few imperfections.

DSCF6946

I admit, I was terrified that I’d have a dud nib (Pelikan and I don’t seem to get along). Things looked OK under a loupe, with slightly misaligned tines and uneven tipping, but nothing terrible. But my first writing experience made my heart sink. I filled with Lamy Agate, and the M1005 simply. Did. Not. Write. It went beyond hard starting, way beyond.

I shook the pen, I wrote lightly, I wrote with pressure, I primed the feed, I tried different paper… and still about 50% of my writing was inkless.

DSCF6949

I flushed and filled with Iroshizuku Kiri-Same, and that seemed to do the trick. Maybe some detritus in the feed, or something in the Lamy formulation that didn’t get on with surface tension in the nib?

In the past I’ve found that Pelikan nibs actually break in over the first couple of days — it shouldn’t happen, but it really does. And now I have a fairly good writer.

So about that writing experience. Compared to my previous M1000, this pen is much less of a gusher, and much less springy. There’s still bounce, but it’s more like a normal pen. The nib is a medium, and it writes a true European medium, in my opinion. Not what I was expecting, but I’m OK with it.

DSCF6965

I take the unpopular opinion that the M1000 nib is pretty ugly. It’s huge, which is nice, but something about the stamping makes it look a little wavy and unsharp, rather like a Land Rover Defender body panel. And the waist of the nib is almost as broad as the shoulders, so it’s not very curvy. Overall I much prefer the look of the Montblanc 149 nib.

DSCF6952

After a couple of days of writing with the M1005 Stresemann, I’m pleased with it. I’d forgotten what a nice design the M100x is, with its quick-off cap, the generous capacity, the smooth piston. And I still love big nibs, particularly when they’re on pens as comfortable as this. The stormy grey stripes are the icing on the cake.

The M1005 Stresemann comes in at between £500 and £550 depending on where you order it from, and in the full range from EF to B. At that price, returning to the Montblanc 149 comparison, it’s still good value, but be aware that if you don’t want the Stresemann finish, you can get an M1000 for under £400 quite easily. There’s a hell of a premium for grey stripes and rhodium trim.

The M1005 Stresemann is a special edition, which means it’s not limited in number (and it’s not numbered on the pen), but won’t necessarily be around forever. If you want one — now’s the time to jump.

 

11 thoughts on “Gorgeous in grey: the Pelikan M1005 Stresemann

  1. Beautiful pen, and a great review as always. It is a shame you keep having such problems with the Pelikan nibs!
    With the bright orange background in your photos, the rhodium trim is all tinted to look gold. The true silver color is only apparent in the tray comparison with your other pens.

    Like

  2. My 1005 came with a B nib. I inked it with Pelikan Miss Green and it writes a wonderful wet line. The nib is very smooth, despite the very slight misalignment in the tines (sigh, they don’t seem to know how to get it right ever). A very handsome pen that writes well. It does, as you said, feel less springy than the nibs in my older M1000.

    Like

  3. Anthony, I’m curious about why you don’t purchase pens from a nibsmith and ask them to tune it to perfection before they send it to you. For a pen in this price range, most would even do nib modification for free, I believe. Anyway, just curious.

    Like

    • I don’t know if any UK-based nibmeister that also sells pens, a la Nibs.com or nibsmith.com. Anyway, for me I want to experience what the manufacturer intended before I put my stamp on it — sometimes I find a nib that I love that is not how I would have ordered it (“grind it to an italic and make it 10/10 for wetness and as smooth as you can get it”)!

      Like

  4. Pingback: UKFP Uncapped: 22nd September 2019 | UK fountain pens

  5. Pingback: Onoto’s new plunger filler is a blast from the past — for a price | UK fountain pens

  6. Pingback: State of the collection: October 2019. Fit to burst | UK fountain pens

  7. Pingback: UKFP Uncapped: 1st November 2019 | UK fountain pens

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s