Going large(ish) with the Platinum President

The Platinum President (PTB-20000P) is one of those pens that nobody knows about. Its value proposition is simple: it’s a slightly fancier, larger version of the 3776, with a more western-tuned nib, now in 18k gold. The only downside, on paper, is that it lacks the 3776’s wonderful sealing cap, but in all other respects it’s a step up from the 3776.

This was music to my ears. Although I loved the nibs on the three Platinum 3776s I’ve owned, the 3776 is just that bit too small for my current tastes, and I eventually got annoyed by evidence of cheap construction, like casting lines in the plastic. At £140 from a reputable UK shop (I bought mine from Cult Pens), the President is about £40 more expensive than the base 3776, but still a real bargain — from most manufacturers you would still be in steel-nib territory.

So consider it no harsh judgement when I say that the President is still not a high-end pen, in my book. Although the story goes that President Clinton used one of these pens, I find it hard to believe that he did so because it was the best pen in his budget.

dscf4148

President. Uh-uh…

Indeed, there are no noticeable mould lines (tick) and the pen is a bit bigger than the 3776 (tick), and there are a few cosmetic differences like the art deco clip, but you’d be hard-pressed to tell the two pens apart without them side by side.

dscf4151

Slightly fancier clip than the 3776

The President still feels kinda plasticky, it’s still a cartridge converter, the clip is basic, and the engraving around the cap band is (like the 3776’s) a bit nasty. Also, the nib is far from flagship size.

dscf4155

Still plastic. Lots of plastic.

Put the President next to a Montblanc 146 and although the barrel is slightly fatter, the President comes off as the smaller pen in almost all respects. The finish on the Montblanc is also a lot better, for example in the flush-fitting of the cap rings. But I recognise that the Montblanc is a lot more expensive, too.

My President is blue resin and gold trim, including on the converter. It’s a very classically styled pen, but the gold makes it actually rather blingy.

dscf4154

A blingy converter

In the hand, I find it very similar to the Montblanc 146; in other words, on the small side, but comfortable. Compared to the 3776, the step down from barrel to section is much shallower, which along with the increased size and generally better finishing makes for a much more comfortable handling experience.

The nib, I’m pleased to say, is absolutely excellent. I went for a broad, which runs a hair wider than the medium in my Montblanc 146 — I’d say it counts as a true western broad, but it’s not crazy. The flow is good, not too wet and certainly not dry. It was perfect out of the box, writing without hesitation from the first touch to the page. The grind is very round, so there’s zero line variation, and the nib is rather stiff: it lifts away from the feed easily, so you get a bit of a cushioned ride, but there’s no flex at all.

dscf4158

Proper broad line

One of the things I like best about the President is how the nib looks. It’s two-tone, with the word PRESIDENT beneath the usual Platinum heart-shaped breather hole, and three swooping parallel lines in rhodium forming the shape of Mount Fuji. The nib’s waist is not as pinched, and it’s top surface is not as flat, as that of the 3776. It’s a rather softer and prettier nib, I think.

dscf4152

What a handsome nib!

I’ve rather spoiled myself over the last year with some phenomenal pens at £400+, from the Montblanc 146 and 149 to Conids, Viscontis, Montegrappas, Scribos and more. These pens are certainly fancier, with more interesting materials and filling mechanisms, greater size and weight, more craftsmanship and bigger nibs.

However: if your budget or your preference doesn’t stretch to £400 but you still want a gold nib in a proper traditional full-size pen (in other words, not a Lamy 2000 or a Vanishing Point), you would be hard-pressed to find a better option than the President. It’s not quite a Montblanc 146 (in brand, construction or filling mechanism) but it’s a very good substitute at a third of the price.

Advertisements

7 thoughts on “Going large(ish) with the Platinum President

  1. Thanks for this very fair and balanced review. It is quite rare to come across anyone who owns one (apart from Bill Clinton, allegedly) and so it is nice to hear what it is like. I am relieved that you got such a decent nib on yours after your recent upsets.

    Like

  2. Nice review! It’s interesting that they don’t have anything in the market above apart from the Izumo, which is both a different kettle of fish entirely, and exactly the same as the President…

    It’s hard to figure out what Platinum’s thinking is as a brand, isn’t it? They don’t get credit for anything they do at the bottom end apart from the Preppy. And, you’d think they could make a decent fist of the 823 / Realo segment of the market if they could step up in terms of materials and filling system (and price it 50-100 quid cheaper than the others). It all seems to be about churning out different versions of the 3776, and sooner or later you run out of colours…

    Like

    • Yeah, exactly, and the special edition 3776s are a much worse value proposition since they’re often quite expensive. I would love the huge range of Platinum nibs in an 823 rival, or as you say a piston-filler like the Sailor. I wonder why there isn’t a King of Pen equivalent too. At some point you need a portfolio of sizes to capture different markets, not just finishes.

      Like

  3. Nice review. I always get the impression that the President doesn’t quite know where it stands in the Platinum line-up. It seems like it might be worth investigating further. You mention the difference in the shape and profile of the nib compared to the 3776, is the nib on the President larger or about the same size?

    Like

  4. Another great review. I tried one when Cult Pens had a 10% off deal and loved the medium nib. Very smooth but was surprised it didn’t have the slip and seal mechanism so returned it. A bit silly really as I don’t leave a pen lying around for a year !

    Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s