The great puzzle of the Pineider La Grande Bellezza

The Pineider La Grande Bellezza is a confusing pen, with some head-scratching design decisions marring what could have been a great addition to the pantheon of Italian fountain pens.

Let me rattle through the basics first. This is a cartridge/converter pen, of pretty good size, with a 14k nib and a metal section. It comes in a nice premium box with some of Pineider’s writing paper and envelopes, so it would make a great gift.

DSC01913.JPG

The list price is about $500, but if you pay that I think you’ve been robbed — this is nowhere near a $500 pen. It feels less premium than the Visconti Van Gogh, the only difference being the Visconti has a steel nib. Compared to, say, a Graf, this falls way behind. Luckily, I paid $260 for my LGB and that’s a much fairer price.

A few things leap out at me as being inspired or nearly so. The quill-shaped, sprung clip is elegant.

DSC01910.JPG

The metal section may divide opinion, but I found it brought the weight balance forward and its pronounced waist gave my fingers a nice spot to rest. The size and proportions of the pen are nice.

DSC01912.JPG

The nib is a real success — although I say that with a caveat. I have tried a few different LGBs, including Penultimate Dave’s B, which is the nicest broad nib I think I’ve ever written with. Mine is a 1.3mm stub, and it’s comically broad, to the point that I can’t really use it day to day.

DSC01917.JPG

All that said, the nib is a “quill” nib, which has an attractive design and some cutaways that promote softness (but not any flex or line variation, at least not in my sample). My stub runs moderately wet and flows well, although it needs a quick tap on the paper to get it started.

Now let’s get on to the problems. First is general fit and finish. The section end of the barrel is raw and unfinished.

DSC01915.JPG

The inside of the cap is similarly rough, with sharp edges from the cap band.

DSC01914.JPG

Supposedly the various coloured resins include actual semi-precious stones to give hardness and intensity. I didn’t much like them so ended up with black, which may have been a mistake: the polish is not particularly lustrous and there’s no depth or texture.

The texturing on the section and cap band is cheap-looking and uneven.

DSC01911.JPG

The finial on the end of the cap is also textured, but not to a matching degree; the finial on the end of the barrel is smooth and seems to be a different metal, so it doesn’t match either.

More about that cap band. Cast into its design is the pangram ‘the quick brown fox jumps over the lazy dog’, which is an absolute “WTF” design decision, inexcusable on a premium pen.

DSC01906.JPG

Inside, the converter is generic. It does the job. “Pineider’ is printed on it, not etched as you might hope for from a premium pen.

DSC01916.JPG

Lastly, the Pineider has a magnetic cap. It functions OK, with a decent amount of pull, but it forces the cap to spin about 120 degrees before it will close, such that the clip doesn’t line up with the nib. This bugs me. It won’t close in any other orientation.

So there you have it: a good nib, comfortable pen, a design with potential (magnetic cap, attractive clip) — but generally mediocre quality and a couple of cheap or vulgar decisions that undermine the feeling of a premium pen. I quite enjoy writing with it, but there are better ways to spend $260. There are MUCH better ways to spend $500.

8 thoughts on “The great puzzle of the Pineider La Grande Bellezza

  1. “Better ways to spend $XXX”
    That seems to be a common line in many honest reviews. What would be your short list of pens in the $100-150 range, and up to $250?

    BTW, I really enjoy your reviews.

    Thomas

    Liked by 1 person

    • Although right now I’m a big fan of the Esterbrook Estie, the Leonardo Momento Zero, and maybe the Franklin-Christoph Model 02 to round out a shortlist of three. My personal per-pen spending budget is probably up at about $350-500 right now, so I’m a little out of touch with the lower end. I’m waiting for delivery of another Visconti Van Gogh, an Aurora Talentum Black Ops, a Karas Ink with gold nib, and a Graf Guilloche. That should give you a sense of my current interests 🙂

      Liked by 2 people

  2. Interesting review, thanks. It is disappointing when the finish lets the pen down at this price bracket. I was impressed by my Pineider Avatar, which at £140 is about £300 less than the list price of LGB and so you can be much more forgiving of sharp cap bands etc but the Avatar’s steel nib was very impressive and enjoyable and the Lipstick Red colour really vibrant.

    Like

    • Yeah, the finish was really disappointing to me. When I first unscrewed the section and saw that unfinished barrel end I actually said “oh come on!” Out loud.

      Liked by 1 person

  3. Pingback: A portrait of the Visconti Van Gogh | UK fountain pens

  4. Pingback: The magnificent seven: week four | UK fountain pens

  5. Pingback: Pens for sale! | UK fountain pens

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s